US: Marketing Under the Radar
Four years ago, Tom Dugan's company did some
work for Peet's Coffee & Tea by covertly plugging a Peet's
promotion online. He'd love to share the names of more recent clients,
but none of them, he says, want to speak on the record. "Most of our
clients are loath to discuss the work we do for them, because they
don't want their competitors to know about it," says Dugan, president
of NewGate Internet, which specializes in search engine and grassroots
marketing through the Internet.
Then again, it's also possible that Dugan's
clients don't want to admit they're paying for chatty postings in
Internet forums-the kind that NewGate and similar agencies organize to
look like the thousands of casual recommendations swapped daily by
forum enthusiasts. After all, it's hard to sneak up on consumers if
they see you coming.
Stealth marketing isn't new, but interest in it is growing as
marketers divert increasing amounts of money from mass media to less
traditional advertising. How mainstream has stealth become? Last summer
California Management Review, published by UC Berkeley's not
exactly radical Haas School of Business, ran a feature called "Stealth
Marketing: How to Reach Consumers Surreptitiously." The authors bluntly
posited that marketers "should attempt to create 'zap-proof' formulas
by relying on more subtle messages that are harder to avoid...to reach
an increasingly fragmented audience."
In other words, time to get sneaky. Plenty of companies use
wink-and-nod marketing tactics, from the largely overt (TV product
placement) to the barely disguised (Burger King's Subservient Chicken
website) to the totally hush-hush (a Hennessy Martini promotion). A
rash of buzz merchants is eager to secretly kick-start positive word of
mouth about your company and its products. But before disappearing
underground, consider some words of wisdom from several battle-scarred
Know this about a stealth campaign: It's a crapshoot. If a campaign
works against your company's reputation or brand image, if vast numbers
of customers hate it, or if a truly covert operation gets blown, your
brand may take a hit. "Sometimes it's edgy; sometimes it pisses people
off," says Jonathan Bond, cochairman of the Kirshenbaum Bond &
Partners advertising agency. "There's always more risk for something
that's new and unproven."
Sam Ewen also counsels caution. "I advise my So why do it? For the right product, at the right time, stealth "On a CPM basis, covert will never compete with TV or radio or Shawn Prez discovered the power of stealth "I have really strong relationships with radio programmers and These stealth techniques are quite effective, particularly with Piquing the interest of adult consumers was certainly a goal of No one from Hennessy distributor Schieffelin wanted to be quoted Sony Ericsson might be the most famous recent practitioner of Dee Dutta, Sony Ericsson's corporate vice president of global DaimlerChrysler has also been active in "We do a fair amount of things like that," says George Murphy, Guerilla in the Mist This means that companies hoping to capitalize on PR-fueled media Not everyone agrees. "I'd rather look at what people are doing and Gauging the success of a covert initiative, unfortunately, can be Although DaimlerChrysler's Murphy agrees that it's difficult to Even with these metrics in place, however, most experts agree that a Would Your Mother Approve?
clients overwhelmingly not to do covert marketing," says the CEO of
Interference Inc., a guerilla marketing firm. "It takes a certain kind
of company, a certain kind of product to utilize it in the right way."
marketing just might be the perfect fit. "Stealth allows you to do
several things right from the get-go," says Jon Maron, director of
marketing communications for LG Mobile Phones. Covert programs "allow
you to get to where consumers live, to where they play, to where they
work in a way that is not invasive and doesn't look necessarily like a
anything else," says Ewen. "But by having conversations with people,
speaking to them as individuals, you can really create a relationship
between them and a product that creates a multiplier effect."
as the national director of promotions for Bad Boy Entertainment and
Sean "P. Diddy" Combs. Now founder and CEO of marketing agency Power
Moves, Prez plans to use guerilla techniques on talk radio to promote a
Discovery Channel special called Rameses: Mystery in the Valley of the Kings.
on-air personalities," he explains. "I'll call them and tell them I
need a 10-minute segment." During the initial promotion, there won't be
any overt mention of the Discovery Channel special, just targeted talk
by show hosts and "street soldiers" (callers lined up by Prez) phoning
in to whip up controversy over the biblical story of the exodus from
Egypt. Closer to the special's premiere on Dec. 5, the hosts will
rehash the topic and listeners will learn about the TV broadcast almost
as an afterthought. If everything goes according to plan, the Discovery
Channel will get plenty of viewers.
teens, according to Prez. "By the time the message gets out, they don't
even know they've been hit; they don't know that they've been marketed
to. All they know is that their interest has been piqued," he says.
Schieffelin & Company when it hired Kirshenbaum Bond & Partners
in the early 1990s to secretly promote a Hennessy cognac brand. "When
we launched the Hennessy Martini, nobody ordered it and nobody knew how
to make it," says Bond. His agency hired 150 actors to go to targeted,
trendsetting clubs and restaurants that didn't serve the brand at that
time. The covert operation ran in eight markets nationally, with 15-20
people in each market. The stealth reps were encouraged to hang out,
order the drink loudly, buy the drink for strangers and otherwise build
directly for this story, but the company did confirm that the promotion
worked. Over the five-year program, bartenders learned to make the
drink, consumers learned to order it, and sales increased by 40
percent, Bond says. The promotion, he adds, produced "new sources of
distribution and made the brand younger and hipper."
stealth, thanks to an aggressive guerilla campaign it used to help
launch a new cell phone with an attachable camera, the T68i, in 2002.
New York agency Fathom Communications hired actors to demonstrate the
phone by pretending to be tourists in seven U.S. cities. The Wall Street Journal's exclusive on the stunt blew the actors' cover, and landed Sony and its phone on 60 Minutes
and in newspapers and magazines across the country. You might think
having Morley Safer knocking on your door would have made Sony skittish
about stealth. You'd be wrong.
marketing, has no regrets about going undercover with the Fake Tourist
program. "For the kind of money we spend, these campaigns are very
effective," he says. The company has also seeded products among
celebrities and was one of the first to use product placement in a
low-key stealth programs. When a redesigned Dodge Durango SUV was
introduced last year, the company tricked up five new models for the
personal use of five sports celebrities. At the end of the three-month
campaign, the vehicles were auctioned off for charity. The vehicle
placement was handled by a third party.
DaimlerChrysler's senior vice president of global brand marketing.
"There's no direct association, no overt marketing. It's just being
seen in a cool vehicle."
Sony Ericsson's Dutta believes the most important element of a covert
marketing campaign-the "absolutely fundamental" requirement for a
successful program-is creativity. "We live and die on innovation. We
want to do things that are not just cool, but different," he says.
attention shouldn't run a me-too campaign, according to Bond. "Do
something that hasn't been done, because those are the ones that get
the press and get the buzz," he says. "Otherwise, it's a waste of
tweak it than reinvent new things all the time," says Ewen, who has run
stealth campaigns for a variety of clients, including Freedom Tobacco.
"There's no reason you can't learn from other people's mistakes and
quite a challenge. Before a stealth campaign launches, "there's really
no way to know if it's going to work or not," says Maron. Adds Bond,
"Most guerilla programs are very hard to measure. It's a leap of faith."
track the ROI on a campaign such as product seeding, he believes that
for most stealth initiatives, "nine times out of 10 you can get your
hands on a measurement." For example, marketers can use toll-free
numbers, promotion codes or custom URLs as part of a covert campaign,
and track response rates to those venues. To see the effects of a
campaign in a specific market, marketers can compare regional sales of
the product or service being promoted. Give a celeb a new car, and you
can track the number of times it shows up on TV.
stealth initiative-more than a traditional campaign-requires marketers
to go with their gut. Because guerilla marketing doesn't always fit
into a neat, easily quantifiable model, marketers "should trust their
own instincts and the instincts of the people who work inside the
organization, says Brian Bolain, the Scion national sales promotion
manager for Toyota. There is no magic formula. I believe this
It's unclear whether consumers are offended by stealth marketing. But
it's apparent that some consumer advocates believe the folks who
produce covert campaigns are little more than, well, lying creeps.
Naturally, the professionals in question beg to differ. "I don't accept
the accusations that we are lying to people," says Ewen. "We're not
presenting things in a false manner. All we're doing is presenting them
in a way that gets someone to pay attention."
Sam Ewen also counsels caution. "I advise my
So why do it? For the right product, at the right time, stealth
"On a CPM basis, covert will never compete with TV or radio or
Shawn Prez discovered the power of stealth
"I have really strong relationships with radio programmers and
These stealth techniques are quite effective, particularly with
Piquing the interest of adult consumers was certainly a goal of
No one from Hennessy distributor Schieffelin wanted to be quoted
Sony Ericsson might be the most famous recent practitioner of
Dee Dutta, Sony Ericsson's corporate vice president of global
DaimlerChrysler has also been active in
"We do a fair amount of things like that," says George Murphy,
Guerilla in the Mist
This means that companies hoping to capitalize on PR-fueled media
Not everyone agrees. "I'd rather look at what people are doing and
Gauging the success of a covert initiative, unfortunately, can be
Although DaimlerChrysler's Murphy agrees that it's difficult to
Even with these metrics in place, however, most experts agree that a
Would Your Mother Approve?
Many pros agree with this logic-within
reason. A teaser campaign that omits the promoter's brand initially may
not keep many marketing executives awake at night. But some draw the
line at top-secret marketing tactics, like the ones used in the
Hennessy Martini campaign. "That's a really risky path to follow," says
Bolain, who believes such tactics are a bad idea, even for the jaded
youth market that many marketers believe is especially well-suited to
covert campaigns. "The younger audience, as much as they say they don't
want to be marketed to, they don't want to be fooled."
Bolain views stealth marketing not as a covert campaign, but as "an
approach where consumers are allowed to pick and choose what
information they find relevant to them." Long before Toyota launched
the youth-targeted Scion-first in California in 2003 and then across
the rest of the United States earlier this year-Bolain and his team
were convinced that the new vehicle wouldn't gain traction without the
use of guerilla tactics. So Toyota kicked off a series of dance
parties, forehead ads and a docudrama to generate some Scion buzz. The
Scion team also placed cars where their audiences congregate, including
shopping malls, to facilitate spontaneous test drives.
As important as the tactics themselves was the fact that they were
integrated into a broader campaign along with more traditional
advertising. "We always said Scion would be layered, not just mass
media, not just guerilla, but a combination of the two," he says.
Toyota's brand of stealth seems to be working: The automaker expects to
surpass its 2004 sales targets for the Scion by 20 percent to 25
Others agree that stealth marketing is most effective when it's used
to support, not replace, multifaceted marketing campaigns. Fathom
Communications hasn't been involved in any covert campaigns since it
oversaw Sony Ericsson's camera phone launch. Not because it disapproves
of the approach, but because it hasn't been appropriate for the
agency's other clients.
"Stealth marketing is not the wave of the future," insists Peter
Groome, Fathom's president. "Staying ahead of trends, finding ways to
intersect with people without invading privacy or generally turning
people off-that is the future. And also the past and present."