Exporting Cures, Importing Misery
Nagamani slaps a wet shirt against a rock. "Oh, no, I only wash clothes
in this stream," she says. "If you bathe in it, you get a rash."
pulls more clothes from her bucket. It's a quiet, peaceful scene,
typical of rural India - if you don't get too close to the dark brown
stream water with its strange odor, and if you turn your back to the
dark plumes rising from a half-dozen smokestacks on the horizon.
his home in the nearby village of Gandigudem, a farmer named Janardhan
points to his abandoned plow, his junked rice mill and his idle
irrigation well and pump. "Around here, if we have good water we can
survive," he says. "Now, without good water, we're finished. If this
pump still worked, the water would be coming out of the ground that
color." He points to my bright green shirt.
"Look at the trailer
I use to haul soil and sand. It's completely rusted out. I bought it
new, on ... " He writes the date in the palm of his hand: 26/11/98. "If
our soil and water does that to steel in six years, imagine what it's
doing to our bodies?" He opens his shirt and points to a rash on his
neck and chest. "I walk a few steps, and I'm out of breath. I'm only 39
A neighbor, Rekha, says that her subsidized rice
ration never lasts till the end of the month. "Before the pollution, we
grew our own rice. Now I can't grow crops, four of my water buffalo
have died, and we're forced to depend on the government."
miles upstream from Gandigudem is the notorious Kazipally industrial
area, home to an assortment of chemical and pharmaceutical companies.
Behind one factory, identified by a sign as belonging to SMS
Pharmaceuticals, tar-like water dribbles over a concrete dam, runs down
a deep gully, and meanders through a barren field beyond.
second sign in front of the plant, erected by court order, lists some
of the chemicals being used: toluene, methyl isothiocyanate, DMSO,
chloroform. It's nearly impossible to breathe anywhere within a hundred
yards of the plant, and it's hard not to retch.
lies in the drainage of the Nakkavagu rivulet, in the state of Andhra
Pradesh. This was once good farm country. The watershed, about 10 miles
by 25 miles, was crisscrossed by intermittent streams, their water
conserved in a chain of 14 small, picturesque reservoirs called cherus
that provided irrigation water during the long dry season.
the 1970s, the area's good water, wide open spaces and proximity to Hyderabad (India's fifth largest city) made it a prime target for
economic development. The first big industrial park was sited near
Patancheru, the Nakkavagu basin's only town of any size. Since the late
'80s, a half-dozen such estates have cropped up across the surrounding
countryside. Over that time, the word "Patancheru" has come to acquire
multiple meanings: a lake, a town, a region, and an ecological
In travel books, India is inevitably described as
"colorful." The term is certainly apt in this area, but with a nasty
twist. Where National Highway 9 crosses the Nakkavagu just west of
Patancheru, the sluggish stream is deep purple. In a dump outside the
Isnapur industrial estate south of the highway, an alien landscape of
grey ash mounds is dotted by clumps of burnt-orange and sulfur-yellow
powder. Asanikunta, a lake bordering the Bollaram industrial estate,
has the color of cabernet sauvignon and the aroma of paint thinner.
The Patancheru region
has fallen into this state through the combined impacts of diverse
industries: pesticides, steel, chemicals and others. The destruction of
agriculture was largely the result of salts, acids and heavy metals
moving from factories into streams, groundwater and soil.
But more and more, the area's biggest problem is drugs - perfectly legal drugs.
domestic pharmaceutical industry supplies its own market of over a
billion people, with plenty to spare. Exports have shot up in recent
years to $2.5 billion and are predicted to hit $6 billion by 2010.
India was the United States' top source of imported antibiotics in
2002. Thirty-five to 40 percent of India's bulk-drug manufacturing now
occurs along a 20-mile-long arc from Patancheru to Hyderabad; that's a
lot of production, and a lot of waste.
Aurobindo Pharma Ltd.,
typical of the larger companies operating in the area, makes a wide
array of products: antibiotics, anti-HIV drugs, antidepressants, drugs
to lower blood pressure, statins to lower cholesterol, cardiovascular
drugs, and remedies for acid reflux, athlete's foot and osteoporosis.
Some of these products, designed to alleviate diseases of affluence,
would hold little interest for most of India's rural population. But
the people who live and work in the Nakkavagu basin appear to be far
sicker than average, hit with diseases of the rich as well as those of
Dr. Allani Kishan Rao has practiced medicine and fought
pollution in Patancheru for 30 years. He says, "Illness rates here are
more than 25 percent, compared with 10 percent nationally. I'm sure it
is related to the chemical intermediates, organic solvents, and gases
that come out of the pharmaceutical plants and the factories that
Finished drugs undergo extensive safety testing,
but, says Dr. Rao, no one knows what the smorgasbord of molecules
currently being released from the drug plants is doing to his patients,
especially when combined with pesticides and heavy metals from other
For Westerners who are now feeling powerless in the
wake of the Dec. 26 tsunami, Dr. Rao has a message: the West, now
directly connected to Patancheru via the global pharmaceutical market,
is in a position to help stop a disaster-in-progress.
In October 2004, Greenpeace India released the results of a study
comparing the health of almost 9,000 people in nine Nakkavagu-basin
villages with a control group of four villages in a non-industrial part
of the same district. Cancer rates in the nine affected villages were
11 times as high as in other villages. Rates were 16 times as high for
heart disease; four times as high for birth defects; and two to three
times as high for skin problems and disorders of the nervous, endocrine
and metabolic systems.
Researchers at Hyderabad's Osmania
University say privately that preliminary data from their own survey,
due to be completed by this fall, do not show such high cancer rates.
But Dr. Rao says the Greenpeace results are consistent with his
clinical experience: "I am seeing far more cancers, heart ailments,
birth defects, and epilepsy than I did in the '70s and early '80s,
especially among children. And I'm seeing a lot of tuberculosis,
indicating that immune systems are being compromised as well."
at Aurobindo Pharma and at Matrix Laboratories (another large
pharmaceutical firm, with plants in Kazipally) steadfastly refused to
discuss the steps they are taking, if any, to control pollution.
Ram, who runs Denisco, a small, specialized chemical company in
Hyderabad, defends the industry. "I would not like to be in the
position of the big corporations that manufacture bulk drugs. They have
enormous production runs, as compared with my small volumes, and their
waste-disposal costs are correspondingly huge. That's a serious problem
in their market, with its cutthroat price competition."
Ram, "The drugmakers I know are very careful to abide by environmental
regulations. To survive these days, they have to export into regulated
markets, and that means they have to follow strict international
standards set by the World Health Organization."
He feels that
India's skyrocketing exports can't be blamed for pollution of the
Nakkavagu basin; on the contrary, he says, international markets are
creating pressure for cleaner, safer manufacturing practices. "It's not
like the '80s and '90s when guys were dumping all over the place."
least superficially, conditions at some of the bigger drug operations
don't seem too bad. At Aurobindo Pharma's Unit Number 5 in the Isnapur
estate, there's a strip of green grass around the factory perimeter,
and the company has planted a mini-forest of eucalyptus, next to a
small shantytown across the road. Residents of the huts line up with
water pots outside one corner of the factory, where a hose providing
safe, trucked-in drinking water has been flung over the wall for their
Dr. Rao takes care to note that some improvements have gone
beyond the merely cosmetic. Air pollution has been reduced in and
around the town of Patancheru, good water is now piped into all area
villages whose groundwater has been ruined, and companies are starting
to install at least some pollution control systems. But in many cases
the more toxic production steps have simply been outsourced.
to the main units of the bigger companies, where they are making
finished drugs for export, and it will all look very green," he says.
"Just be careful not to go to places like Kazipally and Bollaram, where
their intermediates and solvents are being produced."
mid-'90s, all area factories have been legally required to haul their
toxic wastes to a Central Effluent Treatment Plant just outside
Patancheru, on a tributary of the Nakkavagu. In return for the costs
they incur in obeying this law, companies are allowed to wash their
hands of legal responsibility for their effluents.
say that much waste is still dumped in the countryside in the dead of
night, and the CETP's capacity is overwhelmed daily by a flood of raw
toxic input. Its outflow often carries pollutants at many times the
The treatment plant lies about a mile off
Highway 9, on an unusually robust concrete road built to withstand
heavy tanker traffic. Here, too, the odors are intolerable. (Spend time
in the Patancheru region, and it's easy to become obsessed with smells
- and easy to forget about those toxic elements and compounds that are
To find the plant's outlet pipe, you have to cross the
concrete road and clamber down a ravine. Pouring from the pipe is a
stream of coffee-colored effluent topped with thick, white foam. This
devil's cappuccino will rejoin untreated toxic effluents in the
Nakkavagu, which flows into the Manjira River. The Manjira, in turn, is
a tributary of the great Godavari, which waters the highly productive
rice lands of the state's coastal plain.
Bhopal in Slow Motion
in Gandigudem village, Janardhan looks out over the few acres where he
once grew rice. On this day, a group of boys are using the abandoned
paddy as a cricket field. A lone water buffalo grazes on some weeds.
Asked what becomes of the buffalo's milk, Janardhan says, "We'll sell
it on the market, but we sure won't drink it."
farmer, Rajaiah, shows me photographs of three water buffalo for which
he had paid 20,000 rupees (almost $500) each. The animals, to all
appearances well-fed, lie dead in a patch of tall grass where they had
collapsed a few months ago. A half-born calf protrudes from one of the
Demand for pharmaceuticals in India and in the West
continues its rapid growth, while the toxic tide rises in Andhra
Pradesh. Official responsibility for stemming that tide falls to the
state's Pollution Control Board. As one of its many tactics in this
battle, the Board has established a Night Task Force
to crack down on clandestine dumping. But Board members told New Delhi
Television in November 2004 that the situation around Patancheru has
been out of control for so long that the Night Task Force is
concentrating its efforts elsewhere.
Sudden calamities like the
Indian Ocean tsunami or Union Carbide's 1984 poison-gas leak in Bhopal
generate closely watched casualty counts. No comparable statistics
exist for Patancheru's long-running tragedy, but Dr. Rao believes the
toll will climb for years to come.
"We're now into a second generation of toxic exposure. We're seeing another Bhopal - but in slow motion."