ALBANY, CA -- On the morning of Tuesday, September 11, I sent
my children to school as usual. I hadn't realized yet that this
was the day their world was to change forever.
But when my son came home from school that afternoon, he said,
"Mom, I told everyone at school that I am an Indian, not a Pakistani."
In that moment, the tragedy of the terrorist attacks hit me
in my guts.
For here was my son, who had always identified with white culture
because of his white father, now worried about being identified
with terrorists because of his dark skin.
At dinnertime a couple of days after the hijackings, my older
son asked, "We have to go to war, mom? Because it is the right
thing to do?"
For my sons, war is synonymous with G.I. Joes and computer-simulated
explosions. War means wearing cool fatigues, carrying canteens,
and making cute poses with guns.
That night, I talked to my children about the Vietnam War, about
how young men had fled to Canada and Australia to escape it. I told
them that this war could last five, six years, well into their adult lives.
"I don't want you to be drafted, ever," I told them. "No mother
wants her sons to be killed."
Tears began to roll down my sons' cheeks.
I will always remember that moment as the one in which my children
lost their innocence.
The terrorist attacks are the first large-scale disaster my
children have ever witnessed. They do not remember the day of
the 1989 San Francisco earthquake because they were far too
young; my younger son was born that day. They were also too
young to know anything about the Oakland fires or the Gulf War.
If the United States goes into a full-fledged war, it will be
the first military conflict my children will witness. And though,
like most American wars, this one will be fought on foreign
soil, with no imminent danger of the bombing of San Francisco or Oakland,
no air raid sirens and underground shelters, and no rationing or nightly
blackouts, my children will realize that wars are fought, not on screens,
but in real life. They will watch on television as body bags are carried
and they will know that death can happen to healthy young men.
I do not yet want to tell my children what war is really like,
because, unlike most people born in this country, I have lived
in a land where wars have been fought. I remember when India
was at war with Pakistan, and college students stood on street
corners with buckets of black paint to cover the tops of automobile
headlights. I remember having to eat wheat that the Americans
fed to the cows. I remember my father telling us that we were
safe in Nagpur, because Pakistani bombers didn't have the range
to fly across the length of India.
But most of all, I remember being afraid, despite my father's
Until now, their conversations about current events have
centered on the NASDAQ, a hundred ways to save energy, and George Bush's
slips with the English Language.
Now, my children sense that their world has changed in an instant.
Now, my children want to know how much money I've lost in the
stock market -- and I'm afraid to tell them. Now, we discuss
U.S. policy in the Middle East, the recent history of Afghanistan,
and the roots of terrorism.
Now, they are talking about the Indian man who became the first
victim of a hate crime after the terrorist attacks, and wondering
if the absence of a turban will save them.
With every plea not to discriminate against students with darker
skins, broadcast on the school's PA system, my children are
becoming more and more aware of their inferior status in this
And what we don't talk about is just as significant as what we do. We don't
talk about the possibility that this so-called war might invite more
terrorist attacks with more novel methods. We don't discuss the possibility
that next time, we might be the ones at ground zero.
My younger son's eyes fill with tears at every mention of the
attacks. Unlike us adults, who have been numbed by media images,
my children have not yet become desensitized to mass killings.
Until now, they have been enamored of cities and skyscrapers.
On the popular computer game SimCity, they have built many imaginary
towns with famous landmarks. The World Trade Center is the
centerpiece in quite a few of them.
My children are still trying to grasp the fact that the hijackers
were driven to such a level of desperation and dehumanization
that they were willing to commit suicide in order to make a
And they are wondering if one day someone will hate them just
PNS contributor Sarita Sarvate is a nuclear physicist and writer for
India Currents and other publications.
- 116 Human Rights