US: Diverse Coalition Battles AOL's Email Tax

A diverse coalition of groups, many of them not-for-profits, has launched a campaign to pressure America Online (AOL) into halting plans for a pay-to-send email system.

The coalition of 50 groups was announced in a teleconference with reporters and includes political action committee, Gun Owners of America, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, the Association of Cancer Online Resources, the Humane Society, the AFL-CIO, and the media reform group Free Press.

In pressuring AOL, the coalition plans to circulate petitions among its memberships and gather online supporting signatures from the public for an open-letter to AOL available through the web site

AOL, a division of Time Warner, and Yahoo announced in January plans to offer a certified email system operated by Goodmail Systems. Organisations that paid would be guaranteed that their bulk email would be delivered to the inboxes of the portals' email subscribers. The messages would arrive with an icon authenticating the sender, and email subscribers would have had to agree in advance to receive the email.

AOL planned to launch the service this quarter, and Yahoo expected to begin later in the year.

In denouncing pay-to-send systems, the coalition argued that certified email is counter to the open system that has led to the wide adoption of email, which can be received and sent by anyone with a computer. Introducing a paid system, the group argued, would inevitably establish a two-tier system in which only people and organisations willing to pay Internet service providers could be certain their messages would be delivered.

"When there's a free service and a paid service, I can't think of any examples where the paid service isn't better," Eli Pariser, executive director of civic action for, said.

The inevitable degradation of the free service, in the group's opinion, was just one of several problems. Paid email would also place nonprofits at a disadvantage, since many could not afford to pay; and therefore hamper the free flow of information on the Internet.

"The future of the Internet as we know it is at risk here when you allow corporations, such as AOL and others, to impose this sort of discriminatory regime over information and to profit from it in a way that serves no one but themselves," Timothy Karr, campaign director of Free Press, said. "The free information that Americans have come to expect from this very democratic communication tool has become compromised."

AMP Section Name:Technology & Telecommunications
  • 180 Media & Entertainment

Stay Informed